Why Compression Rate Matters
When designing with gaskets, compression isn’t just about fit—it directly determines sealing performance, stress relaxation, and gasket life. Compress too little, and you get leaks; compress too much, and you risk tearing or losing recovery.
The right compression depends on:
-
Material type (solid vs. cellular)
-
Durometer hardness (for solid rubber)
-
Density/grade (for foam and sponge)
-
Application (air sealing vs. water sealing)
Solid Rubber Gaskets
Solid rubber materials—EPDM, silicone, neoprene, nitrile—are measured in Shore A durometer.
-
Typical compression range: 10–30% of original thickness.
-
Hardness effect:
-
40 Shore A (softer): Easier to compress, conforms to irregular surfaces, lower sealing force required.
-
60 Shore A (medium): Balanced; used in general sealing where moderate torque is available.
-
70–80 Shore A (harder): Needs more load, holds up under higher clamping pressure, better resistance to extrusion.
-
Rule of thumb:
-
For air sealing, ~10–15% compression may be sufficient, especially with softer durometers.
-
For water sealing, aim closer to 20–30% compression to ensure reliable barrier under fluid pressure.
Foam and Sponge Gaskets
Foam and sponge materials (cellular silicone, EPDM, urethane, neoprene) are much lower in durometer but defined by density and compression deflection (ASTM D1056).
-
Typical compression range: 30–50% of original thickness.
-
Open-cell foams: Compress easily but can allow air/water penetration unless skinned or heavily compressed.
-
Closed-cell foams/sponge: Better water seal; rely on cell structure to resist leakage.
General guidance:
-
Air sealing: 25–35% compression is often adequate.
-
Water sealing: 40–50% compression is typically required to prevent leakage, especially at joints or irregular surfaces.
Comparing Solid vs. Foam/Sponge
| Property | Solid Rubber | Foam/Sponge Rubber |
|---|---|---|
| Compression range | 10–30% | 30–50% |
| Controlled by | Durometer (Shore A) | Density & compression deflection |
| Air sealing target | 10–15% | 25–35% |
| Water sealing target | 20–30% | 40–50% |
| Load needed | High (torque/clamping required) | Low to medium |
| Best for | High-pressure environments, extrusion resistance | Low-pressure seals, irregular surfaces |
Applications
-
Solid rubber gaskets: Flanged pipe seals, pump housings, engine components—places where fasteners can provide high compression.
-
Foam/sponge gaskets: HVAC systems, enclosure doors, lighting housings, electronics—where lower loads are available and surfaces are irregular.
Key Takeaway
-
Solid rubber gaskets: lower compression percentages (10–30%), strongly affected by durometer.
-
Foam/sponge gaskets: higher compression percentages (30–50%), tuned by density.
-
Air vs. water sealing: Air can often be sealed at lower compression; water demands higher compression to overcome fluid pressure.
Getting compression right is the difference between a gasket that seals once and one that seals for years.